Divinations from the Collective

The Least Popular DnD Opinion: aka "The Problem With Warlocks"

The Least Popular DnD Opinion: aka

I’ll get right to the point: Warlocks shouldn’t exist in 5e

I know, I know - put the pitchfork down for just a moment. 

It’s not that Warlock’s aren’t fun (they are). 

It’s not that they’re game breaking (they aren’t). 

It’s not that the basic concept is bad (blood pacts and oaths with ancient beings are a staple of the fantasy genre, and they make for fantastic storytelling). 

And it’s also not t that they’re particularly broken mechanically (a few talks with your players or creative combat design can mitigate the ole Eldritch Blast issue). 

No - Warlocks shouldn’t exist, at least not how they are built and played in 5e, because they are fundamentally unfair to the other classes.

Let me explain. 

Baby’s First Blood Pact (Warlocks in 3.5e)

image description: an illustration of a pale man with dark hair and a goatee in studded leather armor. His left hand is surrounded in purple flame, as though he has just summoned it with a spell. End description.

To begin with, it helps to take a look at the origins of the warlock class. It first showed up as a class in 3.5e, designed specifically to be able to outpower any other spellcaster of the same level. It’s concept is simple: a spellcaster that gains their powers through a pact with a powerful entity. 

So, an arcane spellcaster whose magic is received due to a body-or-soul connection? Allowing magic power to be cast without a spellbook and intensive arcane study? So...a sorcerer? 5e even suggests “you are favored by an Archfey” as a backstory for sorcerers in the Player's Handbook - that’s almost exactly a Pact of the Archfey Warlock right there. 

This isn’t much of a problem in 3.5e, unless you’re a particular stickler for worldbuilding. There, the playstyle and build of each class varies - you build up to a concept with the features that you choose, which in turn adapt the method in which you can best play your character. For spellcasters, this is usually in the building of your spell list; for rogues and rangers, it’s in the allocation of skill points; for fighters, it's in feats, which they get broad choice from instead of pre-set class features every time they level up.

3e Warlocks, boiled down, are spellcasters that build and play like fighters. 

Instead of customizing your character by what spells they can cast, with casting and play style determined by your class, Warlocks choose Invocations, which are essentially magical feats, and develop their play style in that way. 

These invocations are slightly overpowered, to allow them to outclass their spellcasting peers, but it fits within the play system of the game overall. 

Thus, I haven’t much problem with Warlocks themselves, just 5e’s implementation of them.

Playing a Warlock Today (Warlocks in 5e)

Image Description: an illustration of a woman with all-white eyes in a tattered dress and light armor. She holds a glowing lantern. End Description.

It’s pretty obvious to anyone who even takes a cursory glance at both editions, but 3/3.5e and 5e play very differently from each other. I’ve met plenty of fans who reduce it to “5e cuts down on the math and fiddly modifiers”, but 5e reduces more than that, really. 

5e streamlines the whole play of the game. Each class plays exactly the same as every other - you choose your class, and then your subclass, and you’re locked in. Even multiclassing isn’t terribly useful. It’s a simple path to follow, with minimal customization. There are 5 choices maximum: race, subrace, background, class, subclass. That’s it. 

It plays more like a standard rpg video game than most other tabletops. This isn’t necessarily a bad thing, but it does sort of negate the real differences between sorcerers and warlocks. 

But that begs the question - in a game system where class differences are primarily found through creative setup, rather than playstyle, how do you handle 2 classes that are thematically connected, but differentiated by playstyle alone?

5e’s answer was that it...doesn’t. 

Not really, anyway. They went ahead and built two different classes, for no perceivable reason as far as I can tell. But to make them two separate classes, they had to alter the play style and build between them.

Instead of the normal spell-slots-and-levels setup of other classes, Warlocks get a small number of slots and always cast at the highest spell level, limiting their casting capacity. In exchange, they get more powerful cantrips, spells, and even a variety of martial options, both in the main class features or selectable through Invocations. 

Oh, those Invocations.

 I’ll get to them, just you wait. 

Pacts, Patrons, and Invocations (oh, my)

So, if Warlocks are essentially Sorcerers, why are they so much more popular to play? Surely, they’re not so much more powerful that you’d be a fool not to choose Eldritch magic over Wild?

The answer is that they’re not more powerful necessarily, nor are they inherently more interesting. But here’s the thing:

As I see many people putting it online, they functionally get two subclasses: Pact and Patron. Plus, they get invocations, which the player gets to choose and change out as they level up, on top of the spells which are inherently customizable.

If it were just the two subclasses, I wouldn’t have so much of a problem. After all, Pacts don’t really have that many features built into them. But Invocations are a different story - the fact that you get to choose which ones you get means that you can essentially select and change your class features. It’s another whole layer of choice and options for difference playstyles, customizability that other classes can only dream of. 

This makes them easily the most customizable class in the game. 

It makes them the only custom-building class in the game. 

And it turns out, while many players wax rhapsodic about the streamlined simplicity of 5e - a lot of them really like the increased customization that 3.5e offers, even if they don’t realize that 3.5e offers it. And that makes Warlocks, the class most similarly built to 3.5e classes, very appealing. 

Image Description: an illustration of a man in leather armor standing on a glowing magical circle against a grey background. End Description.

Yes, Artificers also have Infusions which the player can select and change. I don’t have any proof of this, but I’m fairly sure that Infusions were given to them because WotC saw just how popular Warlocks are, and wanted to mimic it. That, or they realized that it doesn’t make any sense to have only one class that allows such a thing, and designed it so that Warlocks aren’t entirely alone anymore. 

Image Description: An illustration of a small humanoid creature riding on a warthog. The creature holds a spear, and has various skulls scattered on the saddle of the hog. End Description.

A Hexed Class (Why Homebrew Can’t Fix the Warlock Problem)

Image Description: A photograph of several sets of different colored dice on top of a dungeons and dragons book. The dice are brightly colored and mostly transparent. End description.

Why shouldn’t they exist then, if they’re more customizable?

People like them - heck, I like them. I started playing DND with 3e, and still favor it in terms of actual play style. Warlocks build more like a 3e class, what’s the problem with that?

The problem isn’t that Warlocks allow for more customization. It isn’t that they’re more appealing to players because of it. 

The problem is that only Warlocks are built like this. 

It’s unbalanced, and shoddy game design to have a singular class have more options and build differently than all the rest. Especially when other classes (particularly martial ones) were stripped of almost any player-selection options in the same streamlining process. 

If Warlocks are built with Invocations, Fighters should have their Feats, Rogues should have their Skill Points (not just Expertise), Rangers should have their Animal Companion Tricks. 

But the fact is, they don’t. 

And while it would be more fun to simply add in those missing customization options for other classes (I’m usually a believer in improving the disadvantaged rather than disadvantaging the already improved), it’s not possible while still keeping that streamlined simplicity that 5e is so praised for - that it runs on. 

It’s entirely impossible for Fighters and Rogues without redoing the former's entire class build, and the entire 5e skill system for the latter. 

The simplicity isn’t bad! Neither is the customization! But you have to pick one, Wizards of the Coast. 

You can’t have your spells and cast them too. 



128 thoughts on “The Least Popular DnD Opinion: aka "The Problem With Warlocks"

  1. avatar Robertabrat says:

    cinemagraph pro iphone free downloadmicrosoft office 2013 excel download free downloadmicrosoft word 2016 crack key free downloadboom 3d para android free downloaddownload firesheep for windows freelenovo z570 drivers for windows 10 64 bit downloadwindows 8.1 pro wallpaper 1366×768 free downloadaudio converter software free download for windows 8 freecrack software download for windows 10windows 10 pro product key 2018 ebay free download

    bootable windows xp service pack 3 free download free
    download radmin 3.5
    musicbee sync to android
    kris gethin day 12
    windows 7 usb dvd download tool unable to copy files free


    chromecast download for pc windows 10
    best internet booster for pc free download
    chromecast software download for windows 10
    windows storage server 2016 standard edition workgroup edition free download
    window 7 wifi driver download for pc
    corpse party free download pc
    baidu pc app store free download
    serial para windows server 2016 standard free download
    adobe premiere pro cc free download windows 8 free
    download ctfmon.exe for windows xp free


    ]buy windows 10 pro product key ebay free download

    alexa bliss theme song download
    chris brown indigo mp3 download
    mcpe 0.15.0 apk
    wallpapers for moto g
    virtualdrive pro

    free minecraft download full game for windows 10download game windows xp free freepepsi man game free download for pc windows 10windows server 2016 standard download portugues iso + serial free downloaddescargar microsoft office word 2010 gratis para windows 10 free downloadwww microsoft com windows virtual pc download aspxwindows 10 home media feature pack 1903 free downloaddragon age origins free download full version for pcsony vegas pro 13 trial free download free downloaddownload gta 5 for window 10

    ]download acrobat reader 7 free for windows xp free

    all i do is win clean mp3 download
    james brown songs free download mp3
    mechwarrior 2 mercenaries download
    auslogics disk defrag malware
    guyton and hall textbook of medical physiology 13 edition download

    lexmark s600 driver
    jnes emulator download
    latest windows 7 free download free
    suitcase fusion download
    windows xp sata drivers download free


    ]windows 10 win95 theme free download

    love pattern lock screenatheros ar8151 driverbmw e60 service manual download freefree download catalyst control center windows 7 freerealtek rtl8723bs driver windows 10
    ]logic x pro download free download

    2006 chrysler pacifica owners manual free downloadrainy paris lock screenmfc6490cw drivershow to convert cdr to pdfdownload free animated cursors for windows xp free
    ]best dvd player for windows 10 free download

    x2x free video audio mergersqlplus download for windows 10 freefrostwire downloadasus fan xpertwindows 8.1 developer preview download free
    ]windows 10 boot screen download free

    how to spread vampiric corruptionsunbeam bakehouse compact manual downloadpcsx2 system errordownload manycam 4.1download razer game booster
    ]gigabyte z390 windows 7 drivers free download

    newsoftwares1993 honda accord service manual downloadwise folder hider portablesqvefrompantech um175
    ]upgrade vmware workstation player 12 to 15 free download

    lsi sata 300 8xplantronics 780 windows 10 drivergigabyte ga g31m s2liphone dfu toolinternet explorer 10 windows xp 32 bit free download free

  2. avatar Robertabrat says:

    java 6 download for windows xp free freelifetime microsoft office 2010 free downloadendnote x7 download for windows 10connect2 download for pc windows 7dictionary software for pc free downloadmicrosoft visio 2016 install location free downloadwindows 10 pro update download free downloadpixelmator logo templates free downloadgotomeeting free download for windows 10microsoft word 2016 table of contents free download

    alienware rainmeter skins windows 7 free download free
    forensic explorer download
    medal of honor pacific assult patch
    photo frame software free download windows 7
    il-2 battle of stalingrad torrent


    old pc games free download for windows 7
    microsoft office standard 2016 download filehippo free download
    can i buy windows 7 online download free
    download game left 4 dead 2 pc free
    pc hotspot software free download windows 7
    download spyzie for pc free
    shadow fight 3 game download for pc windows 7
    windows 7 loader unsupported partition table free download
    jelaskan kegunaan program microsoft office word 2007 free download
    windows loader 2.2.1 free download free


    7 activator kmspico filehippo free download [/url]

    hp compaq 8200 elite small form factor drivers
    netgear wg311t driver
    dlink dwa 552
    hp officejet 6210 all in one printer
    autoruns in filehippo

    windows 10 enterprise microsoft edge free downloaddell latitude e6420 drivers download for windows 10microsoft composite battery driver download windows 10about microsoft publisher 2013 free downloadattack on titan tribute game download pchp ac power control utility windows 10 downloaddownload antivirus windows xp freebitdefender free download windows 7 freedirectx download latest windows 10download windows 10 in virtualbox

    erp 9 download for pc windows 10 free [/url]

    moto x lollipop at&t
    download wii emulator
    centrino wireless n wimax 6150 driver
    amd r9 360 drivers
    burp suite free download for windows 7 free

    dj promixer
    microsoft fix it 50202 msi
    steam_api64 dll crack
    edup wireless adapter driver
    free download unix operating system for windows xp free


    pro x high sierra download free download [/url]

    microsoft lifecam hd 6000 software downloadchicken shooter game free downloadbrother p touch pt 2600microsoft fix it free download for windows xp freeintel widi download windows 7 dell
    [url=https://bit.ly/3zezAzs]]city hunter game free download for pc
    sanam movie 1997 free download18 wos american long haul truck modsasphalt 8 airborne pcsupremefx drivers windows 10download iis 6 windows xp free
    [url=https://bit.ly/2V7yQgI]]final fight game free download for pc
    ?? ??? ????fran bow full download freecamera detector app android downloadhwdn2texas instruments usb root hub
    [url=https://bit.ly/2UWw665]]free download pinterest for pc windows 8
    mg3200 driversamsung blu ray player bd p1600apk call of duty black ops 2hindi to marathi dictionary apppdf to word converter free download full version for windows 7
    [url=https://bit.ly/3eo8Xjz]]free download pool game for pc windows 7
    samsung kies for windows 10wps office portablecorel motionstudio 3dfree download flv player for windows 7microsoft windows common controls-2 6.0
    [url=https://bit.ly/2TktvCl]]free vr games download pc
    filehipsuper hot sunny morning 2015vlc media player 2.1.5hp compaq 6000 pro small form factor driversmemu portable

  3. avatar Robertabrat says:

    hide me download windows 10download 0xc00007b fix windows 10windows 8.1 keygen generator free download free downloadvmware workstation 14 backwards compatibility free downloaddownload whatsapp for windows 10 pc without bluestacksfifa 15 pc game downloadvigo video app download for pc windows xpintel widi download windows 10 freeactivator microsoft office 2016 professional free downloadwindows 7 home premium 64 bit network adapter driver download free download

    counter strike portable ios
    download injector apk
    djvu viewer free download windows free
    wifi key recovery needs root
    magic duels android apk


    sound blaster download windows 10 free
    download nfs shift pc game
    adobe fill & sign free download for pc
    windows server 2012 r2 standard trial download free download
    become a rockstar game download pc
    windows 7 ultimate 32 bit net framework 4.6 free download
    download serial number adobe premiere pro cs3 free download
    download shooting games for windows 10
    adobe illustrator cs6 full version free download for pc
    microsoft office 2013 word chapter 2 short answer free download


    10 home 32/64 bit usb-stick free download [/url]

    convert mkv to wmv
    rise of the tomb raider pc download torrent
    leap office 2000 for windows 7 32 bit free download
    how to sync mediamonkey with android
    sony bravia kdl 40ex720

    cpu cooler free download for windows 10codevisionavr download for windows 10hp laserjet p1102 printer driver free download windows 10cs go full game download for pccara download game ps4 di pcbaidu spark browser latest version free download for pcmicrosoft office pro 2016 ebay free downloadwindows 10 enterprise 2016 ltsb product key free free downloadlogic pro x help forum free downloadatmel studio 7 free download for windows 10

    hypervisor download free [/url]

    cisco vpn free download windows free
    titan fusion dawn of titans
    delta force 1 game free download
    realtek rtl8811au wireless driver download
    dvd43 for windows 10 64 bit

    media drug download
    truth or dare mangobird
    sairat movie dj song download
    mavis beacon typing tutor free download for windows 7 free
    funny farm game free download


    download for windows xp free [/url]

    sweet home alabama free ringtonehp envy 5660 windows 7 driverdead rising 3 pc gameplaydownload adobe musedownload nds emulator for android
    [url=https://bit.ly/3Bvtf4C]]download xender for pc windows 7 8 10
    english to tamil dictionary software free download for windows 7free download megan trainorpce-ac56 driverlabel designer plus deluxegigabyte z77x-ud3h drivers
    [url=https://bit.ly/3ewrri0]]fallout 4 free download for windows 10
    download clock for desktop windows xp freed-link dwa-552ocz guruie terbaru untuk windows 7windows 8.1 download mediafire free
    [url=https://bit.ly/3ivJmGM]]vmware workstation 12 unlocker for os x free download
    gta san andreas for android mobiledescargar serato dj para maclexmark pinnacle pro901 driver download windows 10 freerealtek card reader driver windows 10 hpkeyscrambler
    [url=https://bit.ly/2UVwLob]]football games free download for pc windows 10
    vertus fluid maskwindows server 2003 download freehp deskjet f4288 software downloadpdfelement proica client download windows xp free
    [url=https://bit.ly/2VO7EUF]]download windows 10 enterprise 64 bit pre activated free download
    voat aegisadventure games free download full version for pc windows 7 freesony max live channel downloadhow to make an image transparent in paint.netdownload microsoft access 2010

  4. avatar Robertabrat says:

    download udemy for windows 10adobe photoshop cs6 software free download for windows 10windows 10 wallpaper hd 1920×1080 free downloadmicrosoft visual studio 2013 preparation stuck free downloadmicrosoft office professional plus 2013 full version free downloadfree download psiphon for pc windows 10battlefield 1942 windows 10 download freefocusrite control download windows 10windows 10 july 2019 update features free downloadatheros ar5007ug wireless network adapter windows 7 driver download free

    zuma games free download for windows 7 free
    nvidia geforce gt 745m drivers
    windows 7 readiness tool
    free download tune up utilities 2017
    youwave pc


    free download photoshop 7.0 software for windows 7 free
    free download skype for windows 8 full version free
    windows 10 professional n vs professional free download
    download lite games for pc
    best wallpapers free download for pc
    free porn games download for pc
    affinity designer google fonts free download
    chicken pc game free download
    windows internet explorer 11 xp free download free
    dart windows 10 download


    download for windows 10 [/url]

    nature photo frame app free download
    download episode pretty little liars
    canon ir adv c7260 drivers
    pagalworld game download for android
    virtual windows 7 download free free

    hd vdeck download windows 10 freewindows 8.1 free download full version with key for pchp youcam download windows 10microsoft project guide 2010 pdf free downloadfree games for pc offline free downloadmusic flow pc software for windows downloaddj hero pc download freedownload old video games for pcchris pc free downloadwindows 10 pro volume license price philippines free download

    for pc windows 10 free download [/url]

    delta force: black hawk down – team sabre
    batch convert msg to pdf freeware
    how to make a game in alice 3
    candy fruit game free download
    sniper 2 ghost warrior system requirements

    what is tmac
    steel detailers manual pdf free download
    windows recovery tool download for windows 10 free
    application for windows phone free download free
    vectorworks free download windows


    crashers free download pc with multiplayer [/url]

    ant movie catalogtokyo ghoul mask generatorgb-bni5hg4-950wilcom 2006 software free downloadps3 arkham city cheats
    [url=https://bit.ly/3ri97OZ]]best pc games free download racing
    truck games 3d free downloadcod aw all elite gunsintel i350 driverageia technologygoogle chrome free download latest version for windows vista free
    [url=https://bit.ly/3xPLqjf]]microsoft office 2010 enterprise 64 bit download free download
    video remakermobogenie free download for pc windows 7 freeariana grande 7 rings downloadlogitech quickcam pro 4000 driverdownload music maker jam for pc
    [url=https://bit.ly/3rifKAC]]facebook app free download for pc windows 10
    hp pavilion dv7 drivers windows 7 64 bitethernet driver download windows 10 freeslow motion camera app downloaddownload windows movie maker for windows 7 free full versionamd radeon r9 360 drivers
    [url=https://bit.ly/3rfDK7w]]download kinemaster pro pc free
    yoga vpn for windowsfree download diner dash full versionlenovo solution center download windows 7 freebagpipes ringtone for androidjava 7 download free windows xp free
    [url=https://bit.ly/3kx5p2A]]download highly compressed pc games under 500mb
    microsoft visual studio 2013 cracksound of a cash registeratheros wifi drivers windows 7radios cristianas de guatemala en lineahuman fall flat download apkpure

  5. avatar EdwardTit says:

    windows 10 home error log free downloadbest cooking games for pc free download full versionmicrosoft excel 2016 power query tutorial free downloadopera mini download for pc windows 10 64 bitbloons td download free pcgl552vw drivers download windows 10parallels desktop 13 14 free downloadintel hd graphics 3000 driver windows 10 64 bit download freegame of life pc free downloadcisco anyconnect client download windows 7 free free

    mp4 player download
    ms lifecam vx 7000
    warp speed pc tune-up software
    epson nx 200 drivers
    a hot night at the krusty krab


    free download adobe illustrator cs6 for windows 10
    music maker jam for pc free download windows 10
    drawing software free download for pc
    free pc games download for windows 7 home premium free download
    logic pro x for mac os x free download free download
    download spyder for windows 10
    windows 7 ultimate free download full version without product key free download
    download software for pc windows 10 free
    microsoft edge browser for windows 10 free download
    gmail desktop application for windows 10 free download


    microsoft visio 2013 mega free download [/url]

    microstrategy desktop free download
    download a sound driver for windows 7 free
    download game pubg pc
    free download ccleaner terbaru full version
    smart lock app free download

    adobe illustrator 10 free download for windows 7 32 bitcreative destruction game download pc unblockedvmware workstation 14 free download for linux 64 bit free downloaddownload windows xp media edition 2005 freedownload word starter for windows 10microsoft office 2010 with product key kickass free downloadwindows 7 activator key crack free downloadcool games free download for pcfifa mobile 19 download pc windows 7beauty and the beast pc game free download

    adobe acrobat pro free for pc [/url]

    whistle ringtone for android
    salmos de la biblia catolica para proteccion
    hewlett packard flash drive
    audio driver for windows xp service pack 3 free download
    hp flash utility

    download msvcr71 dll windows xp free
    junk file remover for windows 7
    1972 honda xl 250 manual pdf free download
    hp scanjet 3970 windows 10 driver
    vault of glass glitches


    office professional 2013 volume license free download [/url]

    awrdacpi motherboard drivers for windows 7 32bitmsi 760gm-p34 (fx)microsoft antivirus windows 8 free download full version freemini lyric apkfb tools apk free download
    [url=https://bit.ly/3zdO7LK]]windows 10 home premium 64 bit max ram free download
    hp p4015n driverimagenes de soledad y tristezacall of duty heroes base layoutcall break game download for windowsnvidia physx windows 10
    [url=https://bit.ly/3iyyNmf]]firefox full download windows 7 free
    download google translate for windows 7download mkv player for windows 7guns of glory calculatorwindows 8 developer preview vhd download freefathom dynamic data software
    [url=https://bit.ly/3hY3thH]]download iron man 2 pc game setup
    kindle for pc 1.17trigger external graphics driverupwork download for windows freelego harry potter quidditch world cupuniversal usb installer windows 7
    [url=https://bit.ly/3wZz2MD]]autodesk inventor 2015 requirements free download
    nmd vpn software for window 7mp3 cutter full version with crackwindows 7 dvd drivers download freejava for windows xp download free freemysql download for windows 64 bit free
    [url=https://bit.ly/3zs0ynh]]download emoji keyboard for pc windows 7
    textpad free download for windows freeashampoo internet acceleratorwhat is kanvas cameradriver pack downloadintel graphics driver 4400


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *